Disqualification Order Did Not Prevent Some Work By DQ-ed Counsel.
Yuba County Courthouse. 1933. Library of Congress.
Western Water Co v. Yuba County Water Agency, Case No. C072058 (3d Dist. Sept. 16, 2016) (unpublished) involved a fight over the scope of a water easement between plaintiff successor and the Agency. Plaintiff sued for multi-millions of dollars, claiming Agency took subsurface water without paying for it. Agency prevailed, with the lower court awarding fees against plaintiff and in favor of Agency.
Plaintiff appealed $112,777.40 in fees awarded to Agency for work by a prior disqualified counsel. The appellate court found that the disqualification cases relied on by plaintiff only applied in a client-attorney dispute over fees, not a prevailing party situation. It further determined that the disqualification order did allow for some limited consultation between disqualified counsel and Agency’s trial attorneys, such that the fees were properly allowed.
Comments