Costs, Special Fee Shifting Statute: Venue Transfer Order—Under Penalty Of Dismissal—Ran From Service Of Minute Order, With Plaintiff’s Noncompliance Leading To A Reversal

Failure To Dismiss Case Lead To A Real Reversal Of Fortune!

           In Southwestern Law School v. Benson, Case No. BV032895 (L.A. County Superior Ct. App. Div. Oct. 25, 2019, posted Nov. 14, 2019) (published), a very narrow issue was presented on appeal, with dire consequences for the plaintiff.  The issue was whether a plaintiff which did not pay for costs and expenses, including attorney’s fees, under a venue transfer order under CCP § 399(a), was subject to dismissal based on receiving a minute order on the venue transfer order conditions.  The answer to the issue was “yes,” but with repercussions being of a fairly dramatic fashion.  Plaintiff did not pay the transfer costs/expenses, the defense dismissal order was denied, and—on appeal—this failure to dismiss was found erroneous because the minute order provided notice of what plaintiff should have done (but did not do).  As a result, a civil judgment of $28,341.10 (inclusive of $2,500 attorney’s fees and $95 in costs) in plaintiff’s favor evaporated on appeal, all based on failure to pay a couple of thousands of dollars in venue transfer fees.