Appealability, Costs: Appeal Of Post-Judgment Order Striking Request For Costs Dismissed On Appeal Against Plaintiffs Who Did Obtain A Merits Reversal Of A Demurrer To A Brown Act Mandate Petition

Reason For The Dismissal Was Plaintiffs’ Failure To Adequate Raise Or Brief The Issue. 

            In New Livable California v. Assn of Bay Area Governments, Case No. A159235 (1^st Dist., Div. 3 Dec. 18, 2020 December 18, 2020, published on Jan. 6, 2021), plaintiffs lost a Brown Act writ of mandate petition on a demurrer, a ruling reversed on appeal.  The lower court, in a post-judgment motion, struck a request by plaintiffs for costs, which plaintiffs also appealed.  The appellate court dismissed the appeal based on the abandonment doctrine, because appellants failed to adequately raise or brief the issue.  This is a reminder to practitioners that California reviewing courts usually (in our experience) will not reach out to decide an issue which has been raised summarily without proper discussion of authority or without proper citation to record support cites.